Fallout 4 vs The Witcher 3: Which Is the Better Game?


There is no doubt that Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt were two of 2015’s best games, and are amongst the best role-playing games available for consoles and PC. Fallout 4 lets players build their characters in unique ways in the Boston Wasteland, and is a great RPG experience from start to finish. The Witcher 3, meanwhile, features a mature storyline and superb characters, and was named game of the year by many video game aficionados in 2015.

But which of these games is the best? Is trekking the Boston Commonwealth in Fallout 4 a more rewarding experience than exploring the medieval fantasy world of The Witcher 3? Read on to find out.

1. Story


There’s plenty of drama in The Witcher 3’s story.


It is clear that Fallout 4’s story is an improvement on that of earlier Bethesda’s games. The game’s main storyline has the player searching for his or her missing infant son in the post-apocalyptic Boston Commonwealth, meeting quite a few interesting characters and embarking on dangerous quests along the way. It has some surprisingly emotional moments for a Bethesda game, and refreshingly, is not the typical clichéd “good vs evil” role-playing game story.

The Witcher 3, meanwhile, has a medieval fantasy story based on the novels of Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski, whose books are famous for their “shades of grey morality”. And not only does The Witcher 3 feature adult scenes and content, but protagonist Geralt’s quest for his adoptive daughter Ciri has plenty of great moments and a surprise or two in store for players. In the end though, Fallout 4’s main storyline is engaging and moving enough to stand up to The Witcher 3’s.



  • mickrrussom

    What a joke. Tie? Based on the steam reviews alone its utterly clear that Witcher is better. Plus who wants to look at a dirty brown wasteland vs witcher’s green lush world?

  • Nothing

    Witcher 3 is so much better fallout 4 it’s embarrassing! Which is better? Manimal or Game of thrones?

  • Michael Talon Marshall

    I’m not reading any more pages after the first one – where you actually tied Fallout 4’s story with The Witcher 3s. Did Todd Howard personally suck your cock to put that 20 hour iRobot wasteland knockoff up to par with The Witcher 3’s more interactive, interesting, emotionally engaging and just plain better 50 hour story?

    Fallout 4’s a great, fantastic game in the grand scheme of things but game of the year 2015? Wasn’t even close.

    The Witcher 3 > Bloodborne > Metal Gear Solid 5 > Fallout 4

    Was Fallout 4 better than Dying Light is a better idea for an article than this.